生命裡「失落」、「失意」的必須

粉絲專頁備份

Written by:

手手姐姐的大女兒,去年開始上大學,時間實在過得很快~19年前的她還是剛呱呱落地,半夜12點準時醒來啼哭的小貝比,如今也已經到了上大學的年紀~回頭想想,還真的是挺嚇人的呢!

她大學上的是哲學系,一開始「哲學」對她的腦袋而言,其實是陌生的,本來她很想唸跟幼兒相關的教育,但是也許老天爺覺得她更需要學習點哲學思考,所以她就走進了哲學系的領域裡~得到這樣的結果,她自己不排斥,而我這個壞媽媽則告訴她~一定是妳的腦袋都沒啥在運轉啦,所以老天爺看不下去了,叫妳得好好的學習一下思考才行啊!(然後她會回我~吵什麼吵)

唸高中的孩子,會很嚮往自由且學校不會管很多的大學生活,當然我家大女兒一開始也是。她唸的學校和高中比較要好的同學,完全不同,所以她得一個人踏進完全陌生的地方,她知道那是她的選擇,所以內心即使害怕,還是跨進去了~大學的上課的模式,和高中完全不同,每堂課的教室、一起學習的同學都不一樣,即使是同系,資料表上的同班同學,也因為組別不一樣的關係,也沒啥機會因為時間或相處久了,而自然的熟悉……這對於從小就在體制內學校學習的女兒而言,是頗不習慣的轉變。

當然,她還是有交到了一些朋友,畢竟她的不習慣,同學們也一定有相同的感受,這樣的共通點,會自然的幫助她們擴展友情~就像人到了國外,一旦看到自己國家的人,那種熟悉會自然的凝聚起彼此,但在和人互動與相處的過程中,透過別人,卻是會有機會更看見自己。

我的二個孩子,都不是只會報喜不報憂的人,老二是那種遇到委曲,回家馬上啪啦啪啦唸個不停,比較不必擔心她會把事情藏在心裡,至於老大呢~她比較內歛,事情發生的當下,她不會馬上報告,但也許某一天,她就會講~

有一次她告訴我,比較漂亮的人,好像真的都比較容易被看見吔!因為系上的籃球隊在開學沒多久,就到班上找女生當球隊經理,她說自己明明就跟同學是坐在一塊兒聊天的,可是卻好像沒被看見一樣,那些男生最先問的幾個同學,都是長相、打扮漂亮的,她說自己這個「普妹」,是一直是到最後,因為湊不齊人數,才被詢問的~她本來是有熱情想幫忙的,但因為自己好像是人家逼不得已的最後選擇,這感覺不太好,所以她就拒絕了~

「普妹」是什麼?我還是第一次聽到這個名詞,她說~就是長相普通的人啊~我笑了笑說,媽媽眼中最閃亮的珍珠,原來在別人的眼中,竟是如此的不起眼~這年頭年輕人的困境,確實還挺多的呢!

這件事是發生在大一上學期剛開學,不過我是到了學期快結束時才知道她有這樣的遭遇,我問她自己內心有很受傷嗎?她說當下有一點,不過沒去才是對的,因為那些答應的美少女,其實沒有很認真的做球經的工作,如果她去了~可能別人不做的事,她都得撿起來做,我跟她說~也讓那些臭男生知道,以貌取人的下場大概就是這麼一回事呢!

但是「交到知心朋友」這件事,對女兒來說~似乎還是她現階段的問題,有一天晚上她和我一起坐在床上用棒針打毛線(我這個媽媽怎麼都教她一些老人做的事),她告訴我~自己沒有同學有自信,覺得有點糟,我問她這話怎麼講呢?她覺得有些同學很能跟別人聊,而她卻是一個「句點王」,她想跟人聊,但又不知該聊些什麼,因為同學聊彩妝、聊台北東區哪家店的東西好買,聊曾經到過哪個國家玩……這些事都跟她的生活經驗是不同的,她覺得自己只能聽,而且很難插進這些話題裡。

這真的是她的沮喪~我問她,妳的同學會畫妝上學,妳如果想嚐試,媽媽不會反對妳這個年紀去做這件事喔!她說~她曾經想過,但自己想了想後又覺得~如果為了要融入別人,而去做了這件事,那她就不像本來的自己了,她覺得孤單有點煩,但不是自己更難以面對,所以想了想後就算了~~

她從來不知道,原來交朋友會變成很困難的事情~我聽著她說話,然後陪她想了想~我說:「高中之前的環境,因為同學都是關在同一間教室,大家一起上同樣的課,被同樣的老師教與罵,這樣的環境造就了共同的經驗,友情的發生,也會自然,不過妳現在的環境不同了,許多事得靠妳自己去觀察、明白、理解,想要有怎樣的生活,更是得靠自己的努力去造就,遇到問題是很好的事,陷在沒辦法解決問題的情境中,也是必須的自然,該如何做,才能遇見跟妳臭味相投,彼此了解的好友,這就是妳的功課啦!

原本應該是快樂、精彩、忙碌的大學生活,目前在女兒的身上,好像沒啥看見呢!不過有時候人的快樂、精彩、忙碌,其實也是一種對自己無助的掩飾,所以有勇氣面對每一個不美麗的當下,我反而覺得更是可貴~~相信生命絕對是有能力從渾沌中摸索出自己的能力,而渾沌的情境,也是人自己的創造,因為沒有污泥,哪能出污泥而不染啊!

我想~孩子的辛苦,我這個媽可能也是一種幫兇吧!因為媽媽太怪了,未來,不論她是要掙脫媽媽的「怪」,還是要掙脫社會的「正確」,我相信她會有自己的面對及遇見,我對孩子的未來,仍舊充滿希望呢!

宮崎駿的動畫作品中,「魔女宅急便」裡的可愛小魔女,也因為自我懷疑,陷入了低潮而讓自己失去了飛翔的能力~人人都會有低潮,低潮沒那樣可怕,好好的經驗且走過它,自然人人都能飛了呢!

[mxp_fb2wp_display_attachment src=”https://hands.kidsbook.tw/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/29178971_1900156693359435_3349552686713274368_n.jpg” mime_type=”image/jpeg” title=”55Sf5ZG96KOh44CM5aSx6JC944CN44CB44CM5aSx5oSP44CN55qE5b+F6aCI” body=”” display=”yes” image_display_caption=”no”]

[mxp_fb2wp_display_embed sender=”225513824157072″ item=”photo” post_id=”225513824157072_1900156896692748″ display=”yes” title=”55Sf5ZG96KOh44CM5aSx6JC944CN44CB44CM5aSx5oSP44CN55qE5b+F6aCI” body=”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” pid=”3550″]

分享本文:

發佈留言

發佈留言必須填寫的電子郵件地址不會公開。 必填欄位標示為 *

這個網站採用 Akismet 服務減少垃圾留言。進一步了解 Akismet 如何處理網站訪客的留言資料